快轉到主要內容

卖方保留货物所有权的案例

·573 字·2 分鐘
Y Cheung
作者
Y Cheung
Blogger, Programer & Traveler.
目錄

案情介绍
#

1973年9月至1974年10月,原告荷兰公司(卖方)向被告英国公司(买方)销售一批货物。其中有些货物由被告销售给第三人。合同第13条规定“交付货物的所有权只有在买方清偿了对卖方的所有债务后才转移给买方。”该条款也包括买方利用卖方提供的货物制造产品,规定该制造产品的所有权由卖方享有,作为买方对卖方债务的担保,买方以受托人的身份占有货物,但有权在正常销售渠道向第三人销售。后来买方破产,欠卖方债务10万元。破产管理人证明以卖方名义存于买方银行的款项有3万元,该款项是买方向第三人销售卖方提供货物的收益。

原告主张,对保管人账户中的款项享有物权权益,并追索财产的转售收益。被告承认合同中第13条的效力使被告成为原告供应货物的受托人,直至清偿所有债务,但同时主张一旦将货物销售给善意买主,他们与原告之间的关系纯粹是债权债务关系,在缺乏明示或推定信托时,原告不能享有追索金钱的衡平救济。一审判决合同第13条表现设立诚信关系的意旨,原告有权追索转售收益。被告不服,提出上诉。

法律问题
#

本案涉及的主要法律问题是:在所有权保留延及交付货物的转售收益时,卖方对该收益的权利是债权还是物权权益?

法理分析要点
#

  1. 所有权包括占有、使用、处分和收益。
  2. 对已偿还的部分,双方已没有关系,但未偿还的债务,仍存在债权债务关系,保有货币所有权,起担保作用,所有权属于物权。

相關文章

国际货物买卖合同成立的案例

·1464 字·3 分鐘
案情介绍 # 德国建筑商A于1993年8月底与美国生产商B联系,要求美国生产商B向其报4万吨钢缆的价格,并明确告诉美国生产商B,此次报价是为了计算向某项工程的投标,投标将于同年10月1日开始进行,10月10日便可得知投标结果。同年9月10日,美国生产商B向德国建筑商A发出正式要约,要约中条件完整,但要约中既没有规定承诺期限,也没有注明要约是不可撤销的。同年9月中旬起,国际市场钢缆的价格猛涨,在此种情况下,美国生产商B于10月2日向德国建筑商A发出撤销其9月10日要约的传真。同年10月10日,当德国建筑商A得知自己已中标的消息后,仍立即向美国生产商B发去传真,对9月10日的要约表示承诺。此后,美国生产商B争辩他已于10月2日撤销了要约,因此合同不能成立。双方就合同是否有效成立发生了纠纷。

国际商事合同笔记 第二章Part9

·528 字·2 分鐘
30. NOTICE All notices, including daily communications, to be given to either party shall be given to the following addresses by mail, e-mail or facsimile. Important notices, in which rights and/or obligations of either party are involved shall be given by registered mail, and such notices shall be deemed to have been valid seven (7) days after their dispatch. Either party may change its address by giving prior notice to the other party, delivered in the same manner set forth hereinabove. For the Buyer :(买方地址:)

国际商事合同笔记 第二章Part8

·1967 字·4 分鐘
17. PERFORMANCE BOND, WARRANTY BOND AND REFUND BOND **(**履约保证金、质量保证金和预付款保证金) 17.1 Performance Bond(履约保函) In order to assure the Buyer that the Seller’s obligations under the Contract shall be performed and fulfilled, the Seller shall establish a Performance Bond in the amount of ten percent (10%) of the Contract Price, which shall be maintained from the Effective Date of the Contract to the date plus two (2) months from the last delivery date of the Equipment in the form of an absolute and unconditional bank guarantee to be issued by a first-class bank or any other type of guarantee acceptable to the Buyer and in favor of the Buyer and to be advised to the Buyer as specified in Article 30 hereof through a prime bank or to be directly mailed to the Buyer. The Performance Bond shall be payable on demand and unconditionally at the Buyer’s request for payment which comprises an invoice and the Buyer’s simple statement that the Seller has failed to comply with any term and condition set forth in the Contract. The Buyer shall be entitled to withdraw corresponding amounts out of the Performance Bond in the event that the Seller defaults on its obligations under the Contract.

国际商事合同笔记 第二章Part7保证

·997 字·2 分鐘
16. WARRANTIES**(**保证) 16.1 The Seller shall warrant that all the Equipment supplied by the Seller shall, except for normal wear and tear, be new and free from defects, be of first class workmanship and materials and show no defects due to faulty design, materials or workmanship under normal operating conditions. 卖方应保证,除正常磨损外,由卖方提供的所有设备均应为全新而无缺陷的,是以第一流的工艺和材料制造的,在正常使用情况下不会因错误的设计或不良的材料或工艺而引起损坏。

国际商事合同笔记 第二章Part6损失的清算

·1485 字·3 分鐘
15. LIQUIDATED DAMAGES**(**损失的清算) 15.1 Liquidated Damages for Delayed Delivery(延迟交货的违约赔偿金) In case there is a delay in the delivery of the Equipment beyond the date of delivery specified in the Contract due to reasons attributable to the Seller, the Buyer is entitled to claim liquidated damages per day of delay in an amount equivalent to one tenth of one percent (0.1%) of the contract amount including V.A.T. of the Unit of Supply to which the delayed Equipment Such liquidated damages shall not exceed five percent (5%) of the contract amount including V.A.T.

国际商事合同笔记 第二章Part5合同价格与付款条件

·1324 字·3 分鐘
4. CONTRACT PRICE AND PAYMENT TERMS**(**合同价格与付款条件) 4.1 The Contract Price is made on a fixed price basis and consists of the prices for all the supplies and services in the Article 3.1 hereof. However, the Contract Price is subject to any valid adjustments made through the application of the relevant provisions in the Contract.